High ISO Noise Explained: Why ISO Doesn’t Create Noise (And How High You Can Really Go)

Facebook
Twitter
Email
Reddit

Have you ever heard that you should keep your ISO as low as possible to avoid noise? For years, ISO was my enemy too. Then came this photo, shot at ISO 16,000 in broad daylight, by pure mistake. I expected it to be ruined. Instead, to me, it looks like film.

If ISO has ever confused you, this article is for you. You’ll know where noise really comes from, how far you can push your own camera, and the one setting that caused my mistake. (Spoiler: it wasn’t my ISO.)

Table des matières

What ISO Doesn’t Do

The biggest misconception about ISO is that it creates noise. It doesn’t. And that’s pretty incredible when you think about it.

The light that hits your sensor comes from three things: the scene, your aperture and your shutter speed. Your ISO adds absolutely no light. Not one bit. What it does is turn up the volume of what your sensor collected. That is called gain.

iso is gain turning up the volume reveals the hiss

Think of a speaker. You play a song really quietly, then you turn the volume all the way up. What do you hear? The song, but also a hiss in the background. It was always there. The recording was just too quiet. The volume didn’t create it, it revealed it.

And if you push the volume too far on a loud song, it starts to crackle in your headphones. Keep that crackle in mind, we’ll get back to it.

Your ISO works exactly the same way. In photography, we even use the same word: noise.

Where Noise Really Comes From

From the light itself. Light hits your sensor as tiny particles, like drops of rain on the pavement.

When it’s pouring, every part of the pavement gets soaked evenly. That’s a bright scene: a smooth, clean image.

image noise explained downpour lots of light clean image
image noise explained with raindrops on the sensor in low light

But at the very beginning of a rain shower, the first drops land kind of randomly. One spot gets three drops, the next one gets none. That’s low light: each pixel on your sensor catches a slightly different number of light particles than its neighbors, and with so little light, those differences are big enough to see. That’s your noise.

Your ISO doesn’t add drops. It just turns up the volume on that patchy pavement, so it’s more visible.

The proof in two shots

I took two shots with the exact same light, same shutter speed, same aperture. One at ISO 500 that I bumped up 5 stops in post. One straight out of the camera at ISO 16,000.

iso 500 brightened in post vs iso 16000 in camera at 100 percent

Do they look the same? Maybe from far. But zoom in a little: the ISO 500 one is actually worse. It’s subtle, but it’s also very surprising. It’s not the ISO, it’s the light.

So what about my ISO 16,000 photo?

marquesas beach photo shot at iso 16000 in broad daylight
70mm, ISO 16000, 1/2000s, F/2.8. Edited with my Lightroom presets available here

My friend Jeremy took it of me walking on the beach in the Marquesas, while on a shoot for the tourism board. Right before, I was taking photos of horseback riding on that beach, and my shutter speed was still locked at 1/2000 of a second.

For someone walking, 1/500, even 1/250, would have been plenty. At 1/2000, I let in four times less light than I needed. So my camera turned up the volume, all the way to ISO 16,000.

When I first saw it, I thought: how could I miss this? Then I looked again and thought: wait, I actually love this.

So here’s the important rule: get as much light in your camera as you can first. More light on the sensor means less noise. Then let your ISO do the rest. And never underexpose just to keep that ISO number low: shooting in the dark and brightening later in Lightroom will not save you. The light you did not capture is gone.

(Quick question: do you ever go above ISO 3200, or do you let your ISO run wild? Tell me in the comments under the video.)

The Two Kinds of Noise

If the ISO isn’t the problem, why do some high ISO photos look amazing and others look like trash? Because there are two kinds of noise.

luminance noise fine grain vs color noise blotches
  • Luminance noise: fine, even grain. It can look a lot like film.
  • Color noise: multicolored blotches. That’s the ugly one.

The good news: color noise is also the easiest to remove, and most editing software already cleans it up a lot by default. Your camera does too.

In my experience, older cameras gave me way worse color noise, to the point of being unusable.

sensor dynamic range versus iso chart from photonstophotos
An older DSLR against my recent Sony cameras. Source: photonstophotos.net

Today, with my Sony, I can shoot at ISO 16,000 or 25,600 and be fine. Sometimes it almost feels like grain, just like the photo at the top.

polynesia sunset photo shot at iso 25600
24mm, ISO 25600, 1/4s, F/2.8. Edited with my Lightroom presets available here

Back in the day, I would never push my ISO that far. Now I do it all the time. Everyone has their own limit, and every friend I talk to has a different one. On my A7 V, even the A7 IV and A7 III, I’m happy to go up in the tens of thousands, and in some extreme cases to 51,200.

And honestly, most of the noise we worry about, nobody will ever notice. Especially on a phone screen. I’ve seen big brands buy photos with tons of noise and blow them up on ten meter displays. People were happy with it. The photographer got the job, the photo got printed, it had noise, and that was fine.

How I Pick My ISO

I set it last.

1. First my shutter speed, for the motion. 2. Then my aperture, for the depth of field. 3. Then I accept whatever ISO is needed.

headlamp hikers photo shot at iso 25600
20mm, ISO 25600, 1/50s, F/1.8. Edited with my Lightroom presets available here

Take this photo of hikers with their headlamps. I needed 1/50 of a second minimum to keep them sharp, so my camera went to ISO 25,600 with that aperture. And that’s fine.

A noisy photo can be saved. A blurry one cannot.

So get the light first, whatever you can to get as much light in, and then find your personal limit for your ISO. It’s just like loud music: do you like it very quiet or pretty loud? I like mine pretty loud, so I’ll let my ISO go up to 51,200 sometimes. I’d rather come home with a noisy shot than no shot at all.

iso test at 200 1600 12800 and 204800 same scene at 100 percent

The catch: at high ISO, nail the exposure in camera

An image that you plan to brighten a stop or two in editing will fall apart at those high ISOs. It doesn’t matter if you shoot in RAW or not.

high iso photo underexposed two stops then brightened at 100 percent

Same ISO: one was exposed correctly, the other was shot two stops darker and then brought back. It looks terrible. So make sure you get it right in the field.

The Two Traps of High ISO

I’m not going to pretend high ISO is free. There’s no free lunch, it’s just trade-offs.

Trap 1: your highlights

Remember the crackle in your headphones? If you crank up your ISO without changing anything else, your image gets brighter and brighter, until your highlights turn pure white. And once they’re white, they’re gone. No slider will ever bring them back.

iso 12800 overexposed then darkened vs exposed correctly

Both of these are at ISO 12,800. In the one that was exposed correctly in the field, you can see all the details in the whites. The other one is completely clipped.

It’s not the ISO that kills your highlights, it’s overexposure. When you expose correctly at a high ISO, your highlights are safe. What you give up is in the shadows: that’s where the noise shows up first.

Trap 2: extended ISOs

sony extended iso two bars around iso 50 in the menu

On Sony, you’ll see two bars around some values, like ISO 50, or at the very top of the range. Those are extended ISOs: they’re not native to your sensor, they’re kind of computed.

ISO 50 sounds like it could be cleaner than ISO 100. But look at this side by side:

iso 50 extended vs iso 100 native clipped highlights in red

The highlights clip sooner at ISO 50: I lose about a stop of room in the highlights. So if you want a slow shutter speed in bright light, use an ND filter instead of trying ISO 50.

Sometimes a lower ISO really is the better choice

milky way photo shot handheld at iso 25600
24mm, ISO 25600, 1s, F/1.8, handheld. Edited with my Lightroom presets available here

This Milky Way shot was taken handheld: one second at ISO 25,600. It would have been much cleaner at ISO 1600 with a 15 second exposure on a tripod. In my case, being able to document the moment mattered more than a clean image.

Just know when you’re making that trade-off, and what it costs you.

My Mistake, and the Setup I Recommend

So what was the one setting that caused my mistake? It wasn’t my ISO, it was my shutter speed.

I shot in manual with Auto ISO: I picked my shutter speed and my aperture, and the camera picked the ISO. And Auto ISO did exactly its job. There was little light coming in, so the camera amplified the signal. It did what it had to do.

Here’s what I recommend:

sony auto iso maximum set to 51200 in the menu
  • Leave your ISO on auto and let the camera handle the brightness. Most of the time, Auto ISO does a great job.
  • Set an upper limit for your Auto ISO. I set mine at 51,200 on my A7 V.
  • Keep your attention on what really matters: your shutter speed, for sharp or blurry, and your aperture, for the depth of field.
  • Every time the scene changes, check your shutter speed. Or use aperture priority with a minimum shutter speed, and you don’t even have to think about it.

Your Challenge: Find Your ISO Limit

Grab your camera right now. It doesn’t have to be a fancy scene. Shoot the same scene at every ISO, doubling each time: 100, 200, 400, 800, and so on.

Then look at the images and find where you say: nope, I don’t want to use that. That’s your limit.

But you can go a little further. These two photos were shot at the same ISO. One has been denoised in post.

ai denoise in lightroom before and after at iso 51200

Look at that difference. So whatever your limit was in that little test, bump it up by a notch or two, because you can recover a lot of that noise in post.

In this day and age, don’t be afraid of shooting at high ISO. Focus on creativity and on being out in the field, having fun with your camera.

If you want coaching in the field, where you can ask all your questions and get a custom photography program to practice, find new angles and progress, try Pierre AI and the 60 day photo challenge.

While you’re here, grab my free photography cheat sheet, with all my settings on one page, ISO included.

Next, watch why your photos aren’t looking sharp, and how I was using aperture wrong.

Get out there, go shoot, try something new.

DOWNLOAD MY FREE PHOTOGRAPHY GUIDE CHEAT SHEET

Sign up to get Pierre's free Photography cheat sheet with settings & tips to nail your photo sessions.